By Alex Riggins
The San Diego Union-Tribune
SAN DIEGO — A federal jury on Tuesday convicted former San Diego County sheriff’s Deputy Aaron Richard Russell of a civil rights violation for the 2020 capturing demise of Nicholas Bils, who was unarmed and operating away from regulation enforcement officers exterior the downtown jail when Russell shot him a number of instances, together with no less than as soon as within the again.
Russell, 29, was charged with depriving Bils of his rights beneath colour of regulation and discharging a firearm in relation to against the law of violence. The jury convicted him on each counts.
| WEBINAR: Interagency coordination for large-scale particular occasions
The jury deliberated for only a day earlier than returning its verdict in what was Russell’s second trial; jurors final 12 months deliberated for elements of six days earlier than they have been unable to achieve a unanimous verdict on the identical costs, prompting a choose to declare a mistrial.
Russell is the second former native deputy prior to now three months to be convicted of a civil rights violation in U.S. District Court. In December, a San Diego federal jury convicted former Deputy Jeremiah Manuyag Flores on the identical cost of deprivation of rights beneath the colour of regulation, in addition to a rely of falsifying a report in a federal investigation, for forcefully shoving a closely restrained man headfirst right into a wall, leading to severe accidents.
In each instances, preliminary trials ended with deadlocked juries and mistrials, however prosecutors from the U.S. Attorney’s Office secured convictions the second go-around in every case.
Russell shot and killed Bils, a 36-year-old San Diego resident, the night of May 1, 2020, somewhat greater than a month into the COVID-19 pandemic. Bils had been arrested by California State Park rangers for violating COVID restrictions at Old Town San Diego State Historic Park. As he was being transported to jail, he escaped from a ranger’s car and commenced sprinting away from officers and deputies with handcuffs nonetheless hooked up to at least one wrist.
Russell, who was 23 on the time and had graduated from the San Diego Regional Training Academy a few 12 months earlier, was strolling to work on the jail when he noticed Bils escape from throughout the road. He stepped into the roadway and rapidly fired 5 photographs from shut vary with out warning. At least 4 of the photographs struck Bils, together with one which pierced his again.
Russell resigned from the Sheriff’s Office 5 days after the capturing, and some weeks later, county prosecutors charged him with second-degree homicide, making him the primary San Diego -area regulation enforcement officer to face a homicide cost within the capturing demise of a suspect. He was additionally the primary officer within the state to face a homicide cost beneath stricter use-of-force requirements that went into impact simply months earlier than the capturing.
He pleaded responsible in 2022 to a state cost of voluntary manslaughter and served about 5 months in jail. Technically, he now faces as much as life in jail for the federal civil rights conviction, although he’s not anticipated to obtain a sentence practically that harsh.
Russell had sought early final month to delay his second trial, arguing that he couldn’t get a good trial “given the current political climate” following the latest killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti by federal brokers in Minneapolis . His attorneys had argued that these shootings had “dominated the news cycle,” and that given the similarities to Russell’s case, jurors probably wouldn’t be neutral towards him.
U.S. District Judge Todd Robinson rejected these arguments and ordered the trial to maneuver ahead as deliberate. It started Feb. 17 and lasted elements of seven days, wrapping up Monday morning. The jury deliberated Monday afternoon and Tuesday morning earlier than returning the two-count responsible verdict.
“Mr. Russell is a good man who acted in a split second to stop an escaping prisoner with a shiny metal object in his hand that he thought was a gun,” protection legal professional Jeremy Warren stated Tuesday after the decision was introduced. “Mr. Russell accepted responsibility for his mistake years ago and we are disappointed the federal government wanted to punish him a second time.”
During the primary trial, Russell testified that he believed {the handcuffs} round Bils’ wrist to be a gun. Footage of the capturing confirmed that whereas Bils was nonetheless stumbling after being shot, Russell put his gun again in its holster. Assistant U.S. Attorney Seth Askins argued that by re-holstering so rapidly, Russell confirmed he by no means really believed Bils was armed with a gun or posed a lethal risk.
When Russell pleaded responsible to the voluntary manslaughter cost in state courtroom, he admitted that he “unreasonably believed that I or someone else was in imminent danger of being killed or suffering great bodily injury,” in response to the District Attorney’s Office. He additionally admitted in his plea that he “actually, but unreasonably believed that the immediate use of deadly force was necessary to defend against the danger.”
In 2022, the identical 12 months he pleaded responsible within the state case, the county agreed to pay $8.1 million to settle a federal lawsuit filed by Bils’ household.
In May 2024 , greater than 4 years after the capturing, a federal grand jury indicted Russell on the civil rights violation for which he was convicted Tuesday.
Robinson, the choose, allowed Russell on Tuesday to stay out of custody on bond. Sentencing is scheduled for May.
Billy Leon Kearse fatally shot Fort Pierce Officer Danny Parrish after seizing his firearm throughout a site visitors cease, firing 14 rounds
Travis County District Attorney José Garza stated his workplace isn’t in search of costs in opposition to the officers who fatally shot a gunman throughout a downtown mass capturing
As officers have been working to apprehend a suspect in a car’s passenger seat, the driving force tried to flee, putting one officer with the car and carrying one other contained in the automobile
The new directive bars masks meant to hide id whereas allowing use for security, well being and weather-related causes
©2026 The San Diego Union-Tribune. Visit sandiegouniontribune.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
The annual ILEETA Conference & Expo attracts law-enforcement educators, trainers, and decision-makers from throughout the nation to have interaction in skilled growth, hands-on workshops, and cutting-edge coaching demonstrations