By Jeff Day
The Minnesota Star Tribune
MINNEAPOLIS — Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin has filed one other petition for postconviction reduction in Hennepin County District Court in search of to overturn his conviction of second-degree homicide within the killing of George Floyd.
Chauvin argues his conviction ought to be vacated and he ought to both be given a brand new trial or an evidentiary listening to over what he claims was defective medical methodology and testimony over Floyd’s reason for loss of life, misrepresentation of Minneapolis Police Department coaching and defective jury directions.
| REGISTER: Navigating your first 12 months in management: Insights from new police chiefs
Attorney Gregory Joseph wrote in a 71-page memorandum connected to Chauvin’s submitting that “while the postconviction relief stage of many criminal cases is generally something of an afterthought, this Court is removed from the hysteria of the day and can finally look at the facts and evidence through a clear lens.”
After a 14-day trial in 2021, Chauvin was convicted of second-degree homicide, third-degree homicide and second-degree manslaughter. Judge Peter Cahill sentenced Chauvin to 22½ years in jail, an upward departure from sentencing tips. He was additionally sentenced to a 20-year federal jail time period for violating the civil rights of Floyd and a Black Minneapolis teen over extreme use of pressure throughout an encounter in 2017. Since then, Chauvin has pursued a number of appeals by way of Hennepin County District Court, U.S. District Court, the Minnesota Court of Appeals, the Minnesota Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court.
Those appeals have superior a number of arguments, together with that Chauvin wasn’t given a good trial resulting from intensive pretrial media protection over riots and civil unrest across the globe that adopted Floyd’s killing; that the jury ought to have been sequestered in the course of the trial; and that the trial ought to have been held exterior of Hennepin County resulting from bias within the jury pool.
None of the appeals have been profitable.
The petition for postconviction reduction was filed on Nov. 20 and references a number of arguments made within the common documentary “The Fall of Minneapolis” and guide “They’re Lying: The Media, the Left, and the Death of George Floyd,” each of which have been produced by Liz Collin of Alpha News and closely query Chauvin’s conviction.
The petition argues that Floyd first engaged in “a full-blown wrestling match” with Chauvin and the opposite officers on the scene, Tou Thao, J. Alexander Kueng and Thomas Lane. It states that Floyd’s resistance whereas handcuffed led him to be restrained on the bottom with Chauvin’s knee on his again and neck space.
Chauvin stayed on high of Floyd for 9 minutes, 29 seconds as Floyd repeatedly mentioned he couldn’t breathe and begged for assist. He was declared useless shortly thereafter. The homicide was filmed by Darnella Frazier, who posted the video on Facebook the place it unfold internationally.
A nonetheless picture from that video exhibiting Chauvin together with his knee on Floyd’s neck was proven repeatedly at trial and a number of other MPD supervisors testified at size that it confirmed Chauvin not following division coverage.
Assistant Police Chief Katie Blackwell testified that “I don’t know what kind of improvised position that is. So that’s not what we train.” Former Lt. Johnny Mercil mentioned the picture confirmed a use of pressure that may be approved however solely beneath sure circumstances, which didn’t embody Chauvin’s restraint of Floyd.
Former Police Chief Medaria Arradondo testified that the division skilled knee-on-neck restraints however the stress needed to be mild or average. He mentioned the nonetheless picture of Chauvin confirmed pressure that was not mild or average and that Chauvin making use of that stress for so long as he did was not coverage.
“It has to be objectively reasonable,” Arradondo testified about police use of pressure. “We have to take into account the circumstances, the information, the threat to the officer, the threat to others, and the severity of that. That is not part of our policy.”
He added that there was a “reasonableness” to Chauvin and the officers attempting to get Floyd beneath management within the “first few seconds” however the continued software of stress towards an individual who was susceptible and handcuffed “is not part of our training.”
Earlier this 12 months, Hennepin County Judge Edward Wahl dismissed a defamation lawsuit introduced by Blackwell towards Collin and JC Chaix, the director of “The Fall of Minneapolis.” Blackwell had argued that their questioning of the truthfulness of her testimony had brought about substantial hurt to her and her profession.
In dismissing that declare, Wahl wrote that Collin and Chaix had introduced arguments that have been “substantially true” because it pertained to the excessive threshold for defamation beneath Minnesota’s new Uniform Public Expression Protection Act.
Chauvin’s petition excerpts from Wahl’s order:
“In her testimony, Blackwell stated that the restraint used by Chauvin was ‘not something we train.’ Yet MPD’s own policy manual and other officers indicate that similar techniques were part of MPD’s training materials and policies.”
The petition for postconviction reduction claims that 57 present and former officers have signed sworn affidavits “attesting that the knee-to-neck tactic was trained and consistent with MPD policy.” It additionally argues that Arradondo, Blackwell and Mercil supplied false testimony to the jury, the state made “no attempt” to appropriate it and “Chauvin’s right to due process was destroyed.”
The different main argument in Chauvin’s petition facilities round Hennepin County Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Andrew Baker, who carried out the post-mortem on Floyd, and different medical specialists who testified about Floyd’s reason for loss of life.
Baker decided that Floyd died of “cardiopulmonary arrest, complicating law enforcement subdual, restraint, and neck compression.” He concluded that Floyd’s coronary heart stopped and dominated the way of loss of life as a murder whereas including that the presence of fentanyl, methamphetamine and coronary heart illness have been “significant conditions.” He testified that medicine and different components “did not directly cause the death” of Floyd.
Four different physicians, who relied on Baker’s investigation and photographs of the homicide, testified that Floyd had died of asphyxia.
Chauvin argues that the testimony by these further medical professionals about the reason for loss of life of Floyd failed to differentiate “between forensic video evaluation and practicing medicine” and was an effort on behalf of the state to “discredit Baker.”
The professionals have been Drs. Martin Tobin, William Smock, Lindsey Thomas and Jonathan Rich. All 4 testified that they used intensive video proof from the scene to attract their conclusion that Floyd died from asphyxiation.
Joseph writes in Chauvin’s petition that the video proof is circumstantial and doesn’t shed “any light on the events that took place inside Floyd’s body.” He notes that the Minnesota Supreme Court has discovered that “video evidence alone, without any support in medical findings, is not an adequate foundation for a causation conclusion.”
The petition states that Chauvin can present knowledgeable witnesses from the Forensic Panel, a authorized follow that makes use of peer evaluation to “evaluate forensic assessments for alignment with professional standards,” who will argue that the testimony of these 4 medical specialists about what brought about Floyd’s loss of life “is not generally accepted by the scientific community.”
Chauvin’s petition for postconviction reduction has been taken beneath advisement by Judge Paul Scoggin. The Minnesota Attorney General’s Office is ready to file a response to the movement by Jan. 4, 2026.
Chauvin filed his first petition for postconviction reduction on Nov. 23, 2024. He famous that he didn’t really intend to litigate the problems he raised in that petition — they centered on a tumor that was found throughout Floyd’s post-mortem and questioned whether or not Baker was influenced to rule Floyd’s loss of life a murder. That petition was dismissed in April by Scoggin, who famous in his order that Chauvin nonetheless had time to file one other petition for postconviction reduction however that most of the arguments in his first petition had already been litigated at trial. The ruling additionally famous that Chauvin was in search of appeals for his federal sentence.
Chauvin pleaded responsible in federal courtroom in December 2021 for violating Floyd’s civil rights and was sentenced to 21 years in jail. In his plea deal, Chauvin admitted that when he and the opposite officers determined to not “hobble” Floyd, his use of pressure “became objectively unreasonable and excessive based on totality of the circumstances.” Chauvin’s two sentences are working concurrently, and he’s being housed at FCI Big Spring in Texas.
He’s set to be launched in 2035.
Messages left with Chauvin’s legal professional requesting touch upon the petition weren’t returned. The state Attorney General’s Office declined to remark and mentioned its response to the claims can be made in courtroom.
The Hennepin County Attorney’s Office has served in a supporting function to the Attorney General’s Office all through the prosecution of Chauvin. When requested concerning the petition, Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty mentioned, “Chauvin is where Chauvin belongs.”
The suspect, who instantly met Port St. Lucie officers with gunfire upon their arrival, was shot and killed by return hearth as he tried to shoot officers taking cowl behind a cruiser
“Given that … he remains authorized to work by the federal government, the Hanover Park Police Department determined that he may return to work,” a news launch said
Marvin Morales, accused of fatally stabbing his son, was shot by officers after a pursuit ended with spike strips and a crash on I-5
Former Antioch Officer Devon Wenger was convicted in a single case of distributing steroids to colleagues and obstruction of justice; he was additionally discovered responsible of conspiring towards rights
©2025 The Minnesota Star Tribune. Visit at startribune.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.